Knowledge Agora



Scientific Article analysis using AI

Title Regenerative tourism: a state-of-the-art review
ID_Doc 19
Authors Bellato, L; Pollock, A
Published Tourism Geographies, ,
Structure Here's the analysis of the article with each section described with two sentences:

Abstract


The abstract provides an overview of the article, stating that regenerative tourism is a concept that has evolved over time, but remains often misunderstood. The authors aim to provide a state-of-the-art review of the concept, clarifying its evolution, and synthesizing the critical misunderstandings of regenerative tourism.

Introduction


The introduction sets the stage for the article, highlighting the growing interest in alternatives to sustainable tourism and the need to understand the concept of regenerative tourism. The authors acknowledge the limitations of previous studies and the importance of clarifying the concept of regenerative tourism.

The Development of the Regenerative Paradigm


The section explores the concept of regenerative paradigm, emphasizing the importance of living systems thinking and the ecological worldview. The authors discuss prominent thinkers and ideas that have shaped regenerative thinking, including Charles Krone, Capra, and the permaculture movement.

Applying Regenerative Thinking to Tourism


The authors examine how regenerative concepts have been applied to tourism, including the work of Pollock and Bellato, who have contributed to the development of regenerative tourism approaches. They discuss the challenges of integrating regenerative thinking into tourism scholarship and practice.

The Regenerative Tourism Economy


The section focuses on the concept of regenerative tourism economy, which centers economies and tourism at the center of enquiry and transformation. The authors discuss key proponents of this perspective, including Sheldon, Cave, and Dwyer.

Additional Contributions to the Regenerative Tourism Discourse


The authors highlight additional contributions to the regenerative tourism discourse, including Becken and Kaur's proposal of a tourism value conceptual framework using Te Ao Māori values, and Dredge's suggestions for transitioning towards regenerative approaches to tourism.

The Current State of Play


The authors reflect on the current state of play in regenerative tourism, noting that it has diffused throughout the global community, albeit superficially, and is driven by a widespread hunger for solutions and fresh ideas. However, the authors argue that inadequate attention is paid to understanding the systems-changing implications of regenerative tourism.

Promising Paths Forward


The authors outline three promising paths forward for advancing regenerative tourism scholarship, including the need for new ways of measuring tourism success, the importance of transdisciplinary research, and the potential for collaboration with diverse stakeholders.

References


The reference section lists the sources cited in the article, providing a comprehensive bibliography for readers interested in exploring the topic of regenerative tourism further.

Disclosure Statement


The disclosure statement is empty in this case, as there is no potential conflict of interest reported by the authors.

Notes on Contributors


The section provides brief biographies of the authors, highlighting their background, expertise, and experience in the field of regenerative tourism.

Overall, the article provides a comprehensive review of the concept of regenerative tourism, exploring its evolution, challenges, and potential for advancement. The authors offer promising paths forward for scholars and practitioners interested in applying regenerative thinking to tourism.
Summary Regenerative tourism is a concept that has gained recognition in recent years, but its meaning and application remain unclear. This review aims to clarify the concept by analyzing the emerging literature and discourse on regenerative tourism. Regenerative tourism is a paradigm shift in the tourism industry, focusing on restoration and regeneration of ecosystems, communities, and human well-being. The concept is rooted in the regenerative paradigm, which views life as a complex system of interconnected living systems. The review identifies key thinkers and ideas that have shaped the regenerative tourism concept, including Charles Krone, Donella Meadows, and Paul Hawken. Despite the growing interest in regenerative tourism, it remains misunderstood and oversimplified by many scholars and practitioners. The review argues that regenerative tourism should center on place and its communities to restore harmonious relations between humans and nature. Three dominant patterns stalling the required paradigm shifts in tourism are identified: linear reductionism, extractive growth, and hierarchies and concentration of knowledge. The review proposes promising paths forward for advancing regenerative tourism, including transdisciplinary research, collaboration with diverse stakeholders, and adopting regenerative literacy. Ultimately, regenerative tourism has the potential to transform the tourism industry and contribute to a more sustainable and equitable future.
Scientific Methods The research methods used in the article "Regenerative Tourism: A State-of-the-Art Review" by Loretta Bellato and Anna Pollock are not explicitly stated, but some patterns and characteristics can be observed. Here's a summary:

1.
Literature review
: The authors conducted a comprehensive literature review of the emerging regenerative tourism literature, including academic journals, books, and conference papers.
2.
Analytical and interpretive approach
: The authors employed an analytical and interpretive approach to examine the development of regenerative tourism, its discourse, and its paradigmatic shifts.
3.
Critical discourse analysis
: The authors used critical discourse analysis to analyze the dominant patterns and narratives in the regenerative tourism discourse, highlighting the critical misunderstandings and distortions of the concept.
4.
In-depth case studies
: Although not explicitly stated, the authors seem to have conducted in-depth case studies of regenerative tourism initiatives, using these to illustrate the transformative potential of regenerative tourism.
5.
Theoretical frameworks
: The authors drew on various theoretical frameworks, including living systems thinking, regenerative development, and ecological worldview, to inform their analysis.
6.
Collaborative and participatory approach
: The authors emphasize the importance of collaboration and participatory approaches in regenerative tourism, highlighting the need for diverse stakeholders, including Indigenous communities, to co-create and co-evolve regenerative tourism initiatives.
7.
Meta-analytical approach
: The authors used a meta-analytical approach to synthesize the existing literature and identify promising paths forward for regenerative tourism.

Some limitations and gaps in the research methods are apparent:

1.
Lack of explicit research design
: The authors do not explicitly describe their research design, methodology, or sampling strategy.
2.
Limited geographical scope
: The literature review appears to focus primarily on Western scientific and academic sources, with limited attention to non-Western perspectives and Indigenous knowledge systems.
3.
Insufficient attention to methodological rigor
: The authors do not engage with methodological rigor or debate, nor do they discuss the potential limitations of their own research methods.

In conclusion, while the article does not explicitly outline its research methods, it appears to have employed a range of analytical and interpretive approaches, including literature review, critical discourse analysis, and in-depth case studies. However, there are also limitations and gaps in the research methods, highlighting the need for further methodological development and rigor.
Article contribution The article "Regenerative tourism: a state-of-the-art review" by Loretta Bellato and Anna Pollock contributes significantly to the field of regenerative economics. Here are some key points about the article's contribution:

1.
Definition and Conceptualization
: The article provides a comprehensive overview of the concept of regenerative tourism, its evolution, and its relationship to the regenerative paradigm. The authors clarify the concept's lineage and identify key thinkers and ideas that have shaped regenerative tourism.
2.
Regenerative Paradigm
: The article delves into the regenerative paradigm, its core principles, and its relevance to regenerative tourism. The authors highlight the importance of living systems thinking, ecological worldview, and the concept of a living system.
3.
Critical Misunderstandings
: The authors identify common misconceptions and distortions of the regenerative tourism concept, such as its association with simplistic and superficial understandings of regeneration. They emphasize the need for a more nuanced and context-dependent approach to regenerative tourism.
4.
Transformative Shifts
: The article discusses the need for transformative shifts in thinking and practice, moving from linear reductionism to living systems thinking and from extractive growth to contributing to the health and well-being of places and communities.
5.
Co-Creating Regenerative Tourism
: The authors emphasize the importance of co-creating regenerative tourism approaches with diverse stakeholders, including Indigenous peoples, regenerative practitioners, and place-knowledge holders.
6.
Emerging Trends and Opportunities
: The article highlights emerging trends and opportunities in regenerative tourism, such as the recognition of tourism's role in contributing to social-ecological systems and the need for more nuanced measures of tourism success.
7.
Call to Action
: The authors issue a call to action for researchers, practitioners, and policymakers to invest in training and dedicated empirical research to create a robust grounding of regenerative tourism scholarship.

Overall, the article contributes to the development of regenerative economics by:

1. Providing a comprehensive overview of the regenerative tourism concept and its relationship to the regenerative paradigm.
2. Identifying common misconceptions and distortions of the concept and emphasizing the need for a more nuanced and context-dependent approach.
3. Highlighting the importance of transformative shifts in thinking and practice, moving from linear reductionism to living systems thinking and from extractive growth to contributing to the health and well-being of places and communities.
4. Emphasizing the need for co-creating regenerative tourism approaches with diverse stakeholders.
5. Highlighting emerging trends and opportunities in regenerative tourism.

The article's contribution can be seen in the following key areas:

* Regenerative economics: The article contributes to the development of regenerative economics by exploring the concept of regenerative tourism and its relationship to the regenerative paradigm.
* Sustainable tourism: The article highlights the importance of sustainable tourism and the need for a more nuanced approach to regenerative tourism.
* Co-creation: The article emphasizes the importance of co-creating regenerative tourism approaches with diverse stakeholders, which is a key aspect of regenerative economics.
* Social-ecological systems: The article highlights the importance of social-ecological systems thinking and the need to consider the relationships between tourism and broader social-ecological systems.

Similar Articles

ID Score Article
24 0.806 Inversini, A; Saul, L; Balet, S; Schegg, R The rise of regenerative hospitality(2024)Journal Of Tourism Futures, 10, 1
23 0.772 Ateljevic, I Transforming the (tourism) world for good and (re)generating the potential 'new normal'(2020)Tourism Geographies, 22, 3
1 0.768 Tomljenovic, R; Ateljevic, I Transformative Tourism, Social Entrepreneurs And Regenerative Economy(2017)6Th International Scientific Symposium Economy Of Eastern Croatia - Vision And Growth, ,
10898 0.76 Husamoglu, B; Akova, O; Cifci, I Regenerative stakeholder framework in tourism(2024)
37 0.73 Sheldon, PJ The coming-of-age of tourism: embracing new economic models(2022)Journal Of Tourism Futures, 8, 2
2530 0.715 Tomassini, L; Cavagnaro, E Circular economy, circular regenerative processes, agrowth and placemaking for tourism future(2022)Journal Of Tourism Futures, 8, 3
21877 0.713 Boluk, KA; Cavaliere, CT; Higgins-Desbiolles, F A critical framework for interrogating the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals 2030 Agenda in tourism(2019)Journal Of Sustainable Tourism, 27.0, 7
1337 0.706 Manniche, J; Broegaard, RB; Larsen, KT The circular economy in tourism: transition perspectives for business and research(2021)Scandinavian Journal Of Hospitality And Tourism, 21, 3
Scroll