| Title | Chemical engineering and industrial ecology: Remanufacturing and recycling as process systems |
|---|---|
| ID_Doc | 39 |
| Authors | Salatino, P; Chirone, R; Clift, R |
| Published | Canadian Journal Of Chemical Engineering, 101, 1 |
| Structure | Here are the sections of the article with a two-sentence summary for each: The paper discusses the importance of chemical engineering in addressing the planetary crises of climate change and resource scarcity. It introduces the concept of industrial ecology, which provides a system-level understanding of economic activities from the perspective of industrial ecology, going beyond new technological processes to provide a unique contribution to the socio-economic transition. The article presents a framework for analyzing closed-loop product systems, including re-use, remanufacturing, and recycling. It discusses the priorities for improving resource efficiency, including extending the life of goods in use, intensifying the use of stock, increasing re-use of existing stock, and increasing the proportion of worn or damaged products remanufactured. The paper explores the importance of extending product lifetime and intensifying the use of stock in reducing resource use and generating employment. It discusses the limitations of recycling and the benefits of reprocessing, highlighting the need for a more selective approach to material recovery and the importance of regenerative chemistry in closing the loop on resource use. The article concludes that chemical engineering can play a crucial role in the transition to a more sustainable economy by applying system-level thinking to manage material flows. It emphasizes the importance of extending product lifetime, intensifying the use of stock, and promoting closed-loop use of materials to reduce resource use and generate employment. The appendix provides an analysis of the material balance around the stock-in-use block, introducing a function F(r) to describe the cumulative distribution of service lives in the products entering the system. It derives a simplified equation for the stock S(t) in terms of the product input rate p(t) and the rate q(t) of products leaving the system. |
| Summary | The paper discusses the role of chemical engineering in the socio-economic transition to a more sustainable economy. It highlights the importance of understanding the system-level perspective of economic activities from the perspective of industrial ecology. The authors apply process system analysis to the use, re-use, remanufacturing, and recycling of material products. They analyze four metals - lead, copper, aluminum, and lithium - whose industrial ecologies are at different stages of development. The analysis shows that extending product life and intensifying the use of stock can reduce demand for virgin materials. Remanufacturing goods is preferable to recycling individual elements due to the rapid increase in recycling penalties. Material substitution can reduce demand for scarce materials, but requires vision and foresight to consider future applications. The paper concludes that chemical engineering can play a full role in the transition to a more sustainable economy by deploying new skills and perspectives. The authors emphasize the importance of rethinking product design to reduce the number of materials used in products. They suggest that regulations and policies should focus on increasing the proportion of used goods recovered for reprocessing, rather than the proportion of secondary materials in new products. |
| Scientific Methods | The article presents a research on the application of process system analysis to the use, re-use, remanufacturing, and recycling of material products. The research focuses on the role of chemical engineering in the transition to a more sustainable economy. The research methods used in this study can be identified as: 1. Systematic literature review: The authors conducted a comprehensive review of existing literature on industrial ecology, circular economy, and process system analysis to understand the current state of knowledge and identify gaps in the research. 2. Conceptual modeling: The authors developed a conceptual framework to model the system of material products, including the flows of materials and energy, and the effects of these flows on the environment. 3. Mathematical modeling: The authors used mathematical equations to describe the relationships between the different components of the system, such as the input and output flows of materials, the growth rate of the stock, and the recycle ratio. 4. Case studies: The authors selected four metals (lead, copper, aluminum, and lithium) as case studies to illustrate the application of process system analysis to industrial ecology. 5. Data analysis: The authors analyzed data from various sources, including the European Commission's list of critical raw materials, the US Geological Survey's Mineral Commodity Summaries, and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's Sixth Assessment Report. 6. Scenario planning: The authors used scenario planning to explore different future scenarios and their implications for the transition to a more sustainable economy. 7. System dynamics analysis: The authors used system dynamics analysis to model the behavior of the system over time and to explore the potential consequences of different policy scenarios. Some of the specific methods used in the study include: * Process system modeling (PSM): A method used to model the behavior of complex systems, such as the material products system. * Life cycle assessment (LCA): A method used to evaluate the environmental impacts of products throughout their entire life cycle. * System dynamics analysis: A method used to model the behavior of complex systems over time and to explore the potential consequences of different policy scenarios. * Sensitivity analysis: A method used to analyze how changes in different parameters affect the outcomes of the system. * Scenario planning: A method used to explore different future scenarios and their implications for the transition to a more sustainable economy. Overall, the research methods used in this study are designed to provide a comprehensive understanding of the role of chemical engineering in the transition to a more sustainable economy, and to identify potential solutions to the challenges facing the industry. |
| Article contribution | The article "Chemical engineering and industrial ecology: Remanufacturing and recycling as process systems" by Piero Salatino, Roberto Chirone, and Roland Clift presents a significant contribution to the field of regenerative economics. Here are the key findings and implications of the article: 1. The article highlights the importance of considering the stock of goods and materials in use in the economy, rather than just focusing on flows and waste. 2. It introduces the concept of the "performance economy" which emphasizes the importance of sustainability, social welfare, and environmental impact. 3. The authors develop a system perspective to analyze the industrial ecology of materials and products, considering the flows, stocks, and services provided by the system. 4. They present a framework for assessing the sustainability of resource use in a growing system, including the extension of product life, intensification of use of stock, and recycling. 5. The article also discusses the limitations of the circular economy approach and the need for a more comprehensive understanding of the system properties that define sustainability. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. 3. The article presents a significant contribution to the field of regenerative economics, highlighting the importance of considering the stock of goods and materials in use in the economy, emphasizing the need to shift from linear to regenerative economics, and presenting a framework for assessing the sustainability of resource use in a growing system. The authors' use of mathematical modeling and case studies adds depth and rigor to the analysis, making the article a valuable resource for researchers and practitioners in the field of regenerative economics. |
Similar Articles
| ID | Score | Article |
|---|---|---|
1892
|
0.768 | Broadbent, C Steel's recyclability: demonstrating the benefits of recycling steel to achieve a circular economy(2016)International Journal Of Life Cycle Assessment, 21, 11 |
| 1747
|
0.758 | Gheewala, SH Material recycling in a circular economy-A systems view(2024)Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews-Energy And Environment, 13, 1 |
| 20229
|
0.754 | Birat, JP Life-cycle assessment, resource efficiency and recycling(2015)Metallurgical Research & Technology, 112, 2 |
| 4033
|
0.751 | Somoza-Tornos, A; Pozo, C; Graells, M; Espuña, A; Puigjaner, L Process screening framework for the synthesis of process networks from a circular economy perspective(2021) |
| 580
|
0.748 | Pleissner, D How Can Sustainable Chemistry Contribute To A Circular Economy?(2018) |
| 5593
|
0.746 | Schüpfer, D; Wagner-Wenz, R; Hendrich, K; Weidenkaff, A Materials come around and go around: Adapting to nature's circularity(2023)Mrs Bulletin, 48, 11 |
| 2137
|
0.744 | Reh, L Process engineering in circular economy(2013)Particuology, 11, 2 |
| 20679
|
0.743 | Milosev, I; Scully, JR Challenges for the Corrosion Science, Engineering, and Technology Community as a Consequence of Growing Demand and Consumption of Materials: A Sustainability Issue(2023)Corrosion, 79, 9 |
| 16667
|
0.743 | Ciacci, L; Fishman, T; Elshkaki, A; Graedel, TE; Vassura, I; Passarini, F Exploring future copper demand, recycling and associated greenhouse gas emissions in the EU-28(2020) |
| 38
|
0.738 | Sevilla, DV; Lopez, AF; Bugallo, PBM The Role of a Hazardous Waste Intermediate Management Plant in the Circularity of Products(2022)Sustainability, 14, 3 |