| Title | Technical substitutability of recycled materials in life cycle Assessment: A comprehensive review and framework for quantification |
|---|---|
| ID_Doc | 18033 |
| Authors | Garcia, ES; Huysveld, S; Nhu, TT; De Meester, S; Dewulf, J |
| Title | Technical substitutability of recycled materials in life cycle Assessment: A comprehensive review and framework for quantification |
| Year | 2023 |
| Published | |
| Abstract | In evaluating environmental sustainability with methodologies like life cycle assessment (LCA), recycling is usually credited for avoiding impacts from virgin material production. Consequently, the LCA results are influenced by the manner in which the substitutability of virgin by recycled materials is estimated. This study reviews how the scientific community assesses the technical substitutability of recycled materials in LCA. Accordingly, 49 peer-reviewed papers were in-depth analysed, considering aspects such as materials studied, type of substitution, recycled material (rMaterial) application, and life cycle stages (LCSs) where substitution was evaluated. The results show that 49% of the papers investigated material substitutability through technical and economic aspects. 51% of the articles did not consider the final application of the rMaterial. Plastics were the most studied material, and mass was the most used property to quantify technical substitutability. Certain materials were more analysed in specific LCSs (e.g., metals in the natural resource extraction stage). As 51% of the papers developed a new approach for substitutability calculation, this shows that substitutability is still a concept in development. It was noticed in 33% of the papers that substitutability values were taken from external sources, and in some cases were used without considering whether they were representative for a specific case. Aspects such as harmonization, transparency, and consideration of the application of recycled materials, therefore, require more attention in substitutability evaluation. Based on the results, a step-wise framework to measure technical substitutability at different LCSs was developed to guide researchers in including substitutability in LCA studies. |
| https://biblio.ugent.be/publication/01HGJHVXR0MSZEKA0AHPJH3AWW/file/01HR9YZX9HM5A7J0E4HXSY2XET.pdf |
Similar Articles
| ID | Score | Article |
|---|---|---|
17751
|
Rigamonti, L; Taelman, SE; Huysveld, S; Sfez, S; Ragaert, K; Dewulf, J A step forward in quantifying the substitutability of secondary materials in waste management life cycle assessment studies(2020) | |
| 26442
|
Demets, R; Van Kets, K; Huysveld, S; Dewulf, J; De Meester, S; Ragaert, K Addressing the complex challenge of understanding and quantifying substitutability for recycled plastics(2021) | |
| 13181
|
Daigo, I Life Cycle Assessment for Evaluating Materials(2022)Tetsu To Hagane-Journal Of The Iron And Steel Institute Of Japan, 108, 11 | |
| 13462
|
Vladimirov, V; Bica, I Methodology and calculation model for recycling of composite construction products(2019) | |
| 17214
|
Bos, HL; van Es, DS; Harmsen, PFH On the intrinsic recycling potential of carbon-based materials and products; an assessment method and outlook(2024) | |
| 17125
|
Civancik-Uslu, D; Puig, R; Ferrer, L; Fullana-i-Palmer, P Influence of end-of-life allocation, credits and other methodological issues in LCA of compounds: An in-company circular economy case study on packaging(2019) | |
| 4772
|
Huysveld, S; Hubo, S; Ragaert, K; Dewulf, J Advancing circular economy benefit indicators and application on open-loop recycling of mixed and contaminated plastic waste fractions(2019) | |
| 21543
|
Bayram, B; Greiff, K Life cycle assessment on construction and demolition waste recycling: a systematic review analyzing three important quality aspects(2023)International Journal Of Life Cycle Assessment, 28.0, 8 | |
| 6166
|
Miller, SA The capabilities and deficiencies of life cycle assessment to address the plastic problem(2022) | |
| 10615
|
Briassoulis, D; Pikasi, A; Hiskakis, M Recirculation potential of post-consumer /industrial bio-based plastics through mechanical recycling - Techno-economic sustainability criteria and indicators(2021) |