| Title | A Critical Review of Smart City Frameworks: New Criteria to Consider When Building Smart City Framework |
|---|---|
| ID_Doc | 45008 |
| Authors | Shi, F; Shi, WZ |
| Title | A Critical Review of Smart City Frameworks: New Criteria to Consider When Building Smart City Framework |
| Year | 2023 |
| Published | Isprs International Journal Of Geo-Information, 12, 9 |
| Abstract | In the face of persistent challenges posed by urbanization and climate change, the contemporary era has witnessed a growing urgency for urban intelligence and sustainable development. Consequently, a plethora of smart city schedules and policies have emerged, with smart city assessment serving as a pivotal benchmark for gauging policy effectiveness. However, owing to the inherent ambiguity of the smart city definition and the complexity of application scenarios, designers and decision-makers often struggle to ascertain their desired assessment frameworks swiftly and effectively. In this context, our study undertook a comprehensive analysis and comparative assessment of 33 recently introduced or inferred evaluation frameworks, drawn from a broad spectrum of extensive and longstanding research efforts. The overarching goal was to provide valuable reference points for designers and decision-makers navigating this intricate landscape. The assessment was conducted across seven key dimensions: generalizability, comprehensiveness, availability, flexibility, scientific rigor, transparency, and interpretability. These criteria hold the potential not only to guide the development trajectory and focus of upcoming smart city assessment models but also to serve as invaluable guidelines for stakeholders evaluating the outcomes of such models. Furthermore, they can serve as robust support for designers and decision-makers in their pursuit of targeted frameworks. |
Similar Articles
| ID | Score | Article |
|---|---|---|
39096
|
Ahvenniemi, H; Huovila, A; Pinto-Seppä, I; Airaksinen, M What are the differences between sustainable and smart cities?(2017) | |
| 36249
|
Sharifi, A A typology of smart city assessment tools and indicator sets(2020) | |
| 42487
|
Qian, XS; Chen, MF; Zhao, FC; Ling, H An assessment framework of global smart cities for sustainable development in a post-pandemic era(2024) | |
| 36013
|
Sharifi, A A critical review of selected smart city assessment tools and indicator sets(2019) | |
| 36753
|
Patrao, C; Moura, P; de Almeida, AT Review of Smart City Assessment Tools(2020)Smart Cities, 3, 4 | |
| 35886
|
Hajek, P; Youssef, A; Hajkova, V Recent developments in smart city assessment: A bibliometric and content analysis-based literature review(2022) | |
| 44880
|
Lacson, JJ; Lidasan, HS; Ayuningtyas, VSP; Feliscuzo, L; Malongo, JH; Lactuan, NJ; Bokingkito Jr, P; Velasco, LC Smart City Assessment in Developing Economies: A Scoping Review(2023)Smart Cities, 6, 4 | |
| 36465
|
Sharifi, A A global dataset on tools, frameworks, and indicator sets for smart city assessment(2020) | |
| 44867
|
Anthopoulos, L; Janssen, M; Weerakkody, V A Unified Smart City Model (USCM) for Smart City Conceptualization and Benchmarking(2016)International Journal Of Electronic Government Research, 12, 2 | |
| 40140
|
Domingos, L; Sousa, MJ; Resende, R; Miranda, BP; Rego, S; Ferreira, R Establishment of a smart building assessment framework in the context of smart cities(2024)Built Environment Project And Asset Management, 14, 5 |