| Title | Recycling Nutrients and Reducing Carbon Emissions in the Baltic Sea Region-Sustainable or Economically Infeasible? |
|---|---|
| ID_Doc | 6201 |
| Authors | Callesen, GM; Pedersen, SM; Carolus, J; Johannesdottir, S; López, JM; Kärrman, E; Hjerppe, T; Barquet, K |
| Title | Recycling Nutrients and Reducing Carbon Emissions in the Baltic Sea Region-Sustainable or Economically Infeasible? |
| Year | 2022 |
| Published | Environmental Management, 69, 1 |
| Abstract | Ecotechnologies have the potential to reduce the use of finite resources while providing a variety of co-benefits to society, though they often lack in market competitiveness. In this study, we investigate the sustainability of ecotechnologies for recovering carbon and nutrients, and demonstrate how a so-called "bottom-up" approach can serve as a decision-making instrument. Based on three case study catchments with a focus on domestic wastewater in Sweden and Poland, and on manure, grass and blackwater substrates in Finland, we apply a cost-benefit analysis (CBA) on system alternatives derived from a participatory process. After drawing on an initial systematic mapping of relevant ecotechnologies, the scope of the CBA is determined by stakeholder suggestions, namely in terms of the considered assessment criteria, the physical impacts and the utilised data. Thus, this CBA is rooted in a localised consideration of ecotechnologies rather than a centralised governmental approach to systems boundaries. The key advantage of applying such a bottom-up approach is that it has gone through a robust participatory selection process by local stakeholders, which provides more legitimacy to the decisions reached compared with traditional feasibility studies. Despite considering the revenues of the recovered products as well as the provision of the non-market goods CO2 mitigation and reduced eutrophication, findings from this study indicate that the benefits of the considered ecotechnologies are often outweighed by their costs. Only anaerobic digestion of agricultural wastes appears to be economically feasible under the current conditions, highlighting that further efforts and incentives may be required to mainstream ecotechnologies. |
Similar Articles
| ID | Score | Article |
|---|---|---|
27542
|
Macura, B; Piniewski, M; Ksiezniak, M; Osuch, P; Haddaway, NR; Ek, F; Andersson, K; Tattari, S Effectiveness of ecotechnologies in agriculture for the recovery and reuse of carbon and nutrients in the Baltic and boreo-temperate regions: a systematic map(2019)Environmental Evidence, 8.0, 1 | |
| 6235
|
Haddaway, NR; Piniewski, M; Macura, B What evidence exists relating to effectiveness of ecotechnologies in agriculture for the recovery and reuse of carbon and nutrients in the Baltic and boreo-temperate regions? A systematic map protocol(2019)Environmental Evidence, 8, 1 | |
| 21493
|
Haddaway, NR; Johannesdottir, SL; Piniewski, M; Macura, B What ecotechnologies exist for recycling carbon and nutrients from domestic wastewater? A systematic map protocol(2019)Environmental Evidence, 8.0, 1 | |
| 26352
|
Johannesdottir, SL; Macura, B; McConville, J; Lorick, D; Haddaway, NR; Karczmarczyk, A; Ek, F; Piniewski, M; Ksiezniak, M; Osuch, P What evidence exists on ecotechnologies for recycling carbon and nutrients from domestic wastewater? A systematic map(2020)Environmental Evidence, 9, 1 | |
| 22539
|
Duquennoi, C; Martinez, J European Union's policymaking on sustainable waste management and circularity in agroecosystems: The potential for innovative interactions between science and decision-making(2022) | |
| 22159
|
Zeller, V; Lavigne, C; D'Ans, P; Towa, E; Achten, WMJ Assessing the environmental performance for more local and more circular biowaste management options at city-region level(2020) | |
| 64204
|
Mancini, G; Lombardi, L; Luciano, A; Bolzonella, D; Viotti, P; Fino, D A reduction in global impacts through a waste-wastewater-energy nexus: A life cycle assessment(2024) | |
| 28992
|
Sfez, S; De Meester, S; Vlaeminck, SE; Dewulf, J Improving the resource footprint evaluation of products recovered from wastewater: A discussion on appropriate allocation in the context of circular economy(2019) | |
| 16504
|
Lehtoranta, S; Laukka, V; Vidal, B; Heiderscheidt, E; Postila, H; Nilivaara, R; Herrmann, I Circular Economy in Wastewater Management-The Potential of Source-Separating Sanitation in Rural and Peri-Urban Areas of Northern Finland and Sweden(2022) | |
| 4673
|
Slorach, PC; Jeswani, HK; Cuéllar-Franca, R; Azapagic, A Environmental sustainability in the food-energy-water-health nexus: A new methodology and an application to food waste in a circular economy(2020) |