| Title | The failure of transparency as self-regulation |
|---|---|
| ID_Doc | 68046 |
| Authors | Vigneau, L; Adams, CA |
| Title | The failure of transparency as self-regulation |
| Year | 2023 |
| Published | Sustainability Accounting Management And Policy Journal, 14, 4 |
| Abstract | PurposeThis paper aims to examine the existence of a transparency gap between voluntary external sustainability reporting and internal sustainability performance of an organisation arising from the operationalisation of transparency as an instrumental tool. Design/methodology/approachThis study combined an analysis of a firm's sustainability report (secondary data) with a qualitative case study data (primary data comprising interviews, meetings and internal documents) to understand how the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) sustainability reporting guidelines are applied in practice. FindingsBy comparing what is reported with a range of primary case study data, this study finds evidence of transparency gaps, particularly in terms of the quality of measurement of sustainability performance, the materiality of issues covered and the completeness of the report. This study posits that voluntary disclosures following the GRI guidelines (transparency technique) shape the external expression of acceptable corporate behaviour (transparency norm) that is nevertheless at odds with actual behaviour or performance. Practical implicationsThe findings indicate the importance of mandatory sustainability reporting requirements that facilitate accountability to all key stakeholders and that are externally assured and enforced. Such requirements might take the form of standards that put boundaries on judgement and address material sustainable development impacts and that are accompanied by implementation guidance. Non-financial assurance practices must be developed to cover adherence to reporting principles and processes. Social implicationsTransparency gaps that result from voluntary disclosure guidelines or standards being used to imply a transparency norm may undermine accountability for the impacts of the organisation and hinder alignment of business models and corporate strategies with sustainable development. Originality/valueThe paper contributes to a theoretical understanding of transparency as a form of self-regulation and has implications for the further development of sustainability reporting standards. |
| https://durham-repository.worktribe.com/preview/1186428/37421.PDF |
Similar Articles
| ID | Score | Article |
|---|---|---|
66860
|
Abela, M A new direction? The mainstreaming" of sustainability reporting"(2022)Sustainability Accounting Management And Policy Journal, 13, 6 | |
| 27509
|
Asogwa, IE; Varua, ME; Humphreys, P; Datt, R Understanding Sustainability Reporting in Non-Governmental Organisations: A Systematic Review of Reporting Practices, Drivers, Barriers and Paths for Future Research(2021)Sustainability, 13.0, 18 | |
| 31134
|
Khan, PA; Johl, SK; Johl, SK Does adoption of ISO 56002-2019 and green innovation reporting enhance the firm sustainable development goal performance? An emerging paradigm(2021)Business Strategy And The Environment, 30, 7 | |
| 69755
|
Goel, P Rising standards of sustainability reporting in India A study of impact of reforms in disclosure norms on corporate performance(2021)Journal Of Indian Business Research, 13.0, 1 | |
| 77696
|
Erin, OA; Bamigboye, OA; Oyewo, B Sustainable development goals (SDG) reporting: an analysis of disclosure(2022)Journal Of Accounting In Emerging Economies, 12, 5 | |
| 68096
|
Oncioiu, I; Popescu, DM; Aviana, AE; Serban, A; Rotaru, F; Petrescu, M; Marin-Pantelescu, A The Role of Environmental, Social, and Governance Disclosure in Financial Transparency(2020)Sustainability, 12, 17 | |
| 68908
|
Juusola, K; Srouji, R Challenges associated with sustainability accounting and reporting practices: a legitimacy perspective(2023)International Journal Of Law And Management, 65, 1 | |
| 76389
|
Ofori-Owusu, C; Owusu, GMY; Agyenim-Boateng, C; Welbeck, EES What Drives the Sustainability Reporting Intentions of Firms?(2024)Sustainability, 16, 12 | |
| 70942
|
Galeone, G; Onorato, G; Shini, M; Dell'Atti, V Climate-related financial disclosure in integrated reporting: what is the impact on the business model? The case of Poste Italiane(2023)Accounting Research Journal, 36.0, 1 | |
| 72930
|
Izzo, MF; Ciaburri, M; Tiscini, R The Challenge of Sustainable Development Goal Reporting: The First Evidence from Italian Listed Companies(2020)Sustainability, 12, 8 |