| Title | Sustainability transitions to circular cities: Experimentation between urban vitalism and mechanism |
|---|---|
| ID_Doc | 25262 |
| Authors | Winslow, J; Coenen, L |
| Title | Sustainability transitions to circular cities: Experimentation between urban vitalism and mechanism |
| Year | 2023 |
| Published | |
| Abstract | The "circular city" is a recent addition to a string of urban sustainability concepts that call for transformative changes in the way we plan, build and (re-)shape cities. However, it is often criticised for its ambiguity. Experimentation is a prevalent mode of urban governance for realising transformative ambitions in the face of deep uncertainty and ambiguity, yet it is highly malleable for diverse (and vested) interests. This conceptual article explores the circular city as a boundary object which can have multiple translations amongst actors working toward a seemingly common goal. Based on examples of circular experimentation in the existing literature, we characterise mechanistic and vitalist worldviews of the circular city-where the former views the city as a controllable mechanical system while the latter likens the city to a living being. We identify contradictions between mechanistic and vitalist tendencies within the visions, networks and learning processes of circular experimentation. We argue that boundary objects can be a useful tool for facilitating a productive dialectic between worldviews in urban experimentation, using contradiction as a driver of change. We conclude with recommendations for facilitating a dialectical approach to experimentation and suggestions for further research. |
| https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities.2023.104531 |
Similar Articles
| ID | Score | Article |
|---|---|---|
20328
|
Marin, J; De Meulder, B Interpreting Circularity. Circular City Representations Concealing Transition Drivers(2018)Sustainability, 10, 5 | |
| 20498
|
Prendeville, S; Cherim, E; Bocken, N Circular Cities: Mapping Six Cities in Transition(2018) | |
| 5339
|
Buizer, M; Lata, IB; van de Weijer, J Circularity on what grounds? Advancing learning for circular area development at the interface of proximity and precarity(2024) | |
| 2145
|
Fratini, CF; Georg, S; Jorgensen, MS Exploring circular economy imaginaries in European cities: A research agenda for the governance of urban sustainability transitions(2019) | |
| 27544
|
Soto, C; Thomson, CS; Nchor, JU Realizing the potential for circularity in Glasgow through the socio-spatial dimension of urban systems(2024) | |
| 24934
|
Williams, J Circular Cities: What Are the Benefits of Circular Development?(2021)Sustainability, 13, 10 | |
| 7029
|
Visconti, C Degrowing circular cities: emerging socio-technical experiments for Transition(2021) | |
| 22743
|
Verga, GC; Khan, AZ Space Matters: Barriers and Enablers for Embedding Urban Circularity Practices in the Brussels Capital Region(2022) | |
| 21230
|
Horn, E; Proksch, G Symbiotic and Regenerative Sustainability Frameworks: Moving Towards Circular City Implementation(2022) | |
| 23891
|
Williams, J The role of spatial planning in transitioning to circular urban development(2020)Urban Geography, 41, 6 |